@CraftyMugCafe Tap one item, scroll down to the bottom and you can toggle the dollar discount on or off.
typically if you have a 1$ discount you would make a discount, put in the dollar amount (1$) and when you hit that button it will take 1$ off the item. If you have applied the 1$ discount to several items through the use of rules may be why it is applying to every eligible item.
Either way, you may have to do this a little more manually for it to work for you.
Donnie-M
Square Community