I have a category that is not displaying. I've tried recreating it and all of the below steps;
I've also tried re-ordering. What am I missing?
Yeah, looks like you've been through the standard checklist you see floating around here, so here are a couple of other things to try that might help.
The first is the two category lists. Take a look at Items > Site Categories and see whether the category actually shows up there, not just in the dashboard's Items > Categories. They don't always stay in sync, and recreating the category on one side doesn't do anything if the other side never got it. While you're in there, check the three-dot menu on the category isn't set to hide it from the site.
The second is the Shop All link itself. In the editor, under Links, the Shop All link has a box for automatically linking categories to it. And the Shop All page section can be set to show all categories or just selected ones, so if yours is on selected, a recreated category needs adding back by hand before it'll show.
If all of that checks out, there may be nothing left to fix on your end. Square acknowledged a known issue a while back where categories stop showing in the site navigation, turned out to be sync delays on their side, and it seemed to flare up around their migrations too. Worth publishing, waiting a day or so, and checking again. If it's still missing, I'd run it past Square Support with your site address, the category name, and what you've already tried.
Square Community
Square Products